Mailbag #3: Summer Edition

July 13, 2017

Nathan & Brendan dive into a brand-new mailbag that includes disturbing movies from their youth (shoutout to the Film Roast peeps, yo!), Brendan wishing ill upon a certain "iconic" Michael Keaton character, outdoor screenings that should not be attended by children and the nightmare world where a sequel to Baywatch is made.

They also discuss their next upcoming episode which will be a movie that features a not-so-politically correct performance from Johnny Depp in a film that flopped hard. Yes, that's right. Next week - the Summer Flopbusters begin!

Plus: Will Nathan continue his grammar war?

Be sure to send us more questions on Twitter (, Facebook ( or e-mail us (!

PS: Any questions we didn't get to this time WILL be answered on the next Mailbag.

What Were They Thinking is sponsored by, HostGator (use the coupon code 'schlock' for 25% off your first purchase) and

Malt Shop Bop
Kevin MacLeod (
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License